Disclosure · No affiliate links yet: the store links on this page are ordinary links and earn Seoulvanie nothing. We will swap in affiliate links only after a program approves us, and this note will change then. Brands can't pay for our picks.
Cleansing milk roundup · Korea view
7 Korean Cleansing Milks Compared: Which One Fits Your Skin?
Seven Korean cleansing milks matched to skin type and makeup, from Olive Young KR sales (1 Oct 2026), Hwahae ratings (24 Sep 2026) and Korean review data.
7 products compared · Korean data as of Olive Young Korea 1 Oct 2026 · Hwahae 24 Sep 2026
By Seoulvanie Editorial · Published 2026-10-01 · Updated 2026-10-01
The short answer
If you mostly wear sunscreen or a light base and want one gentle, no-foam cleansing step, start with make p:rem's cleansing milk, the everyday pick in Korea's review and sales data. On Hwahae, Korea's ingredient-and-review app, it ranks first among cleansing lotions and creams at 4.66 from 9,152 reviews (24 Sep 2026).
None of these seven is a waterproof makeup remover; brands and Korean reviews point to a separate remover for heavy makeup.
How we picked · Research-based — not personally tested · Korean data as of Olive Young Korea 1 Oct 2026 · Hwahae 24 Sep 2026 · How we research →
How we chose and ordered these products
Pool: Olive Young KR water/milk sales top 48 (1 Oct 2026) and Hwahae's cleansing lotion/cream top 20 (24 Sep 2026).
Left out: Hwahae #3 and #5 (not at Olive Young KR or Global), #7 and #8 (reserves; Blanc Nature took the last place as the only foam, with higher Olive Young sales), non-Korean brands, balms and hybrids. Logbe is the one Korea-only pick (Hwahae award 2026 H1).
Order: sold in the US first, then by Hwahae rank (24 Sep 2026); Korea-only last.
The 1 product with an Olive Young Korea rank reached it through a promotional listing (influencer pick, Olive Young pick, collab or sale).
◎ Strong fit○ Fits△ Check first× Not a fit— No comparable independent data
How each mark is set
Dry skin: △ 3+ independent sources report tightness; ○ 35%+ say good for dry skin (survey); ○ 'moisturizing' in 15%+ of reviews; △ under 35% say good for dry skin; — no comparable independent data
Oily / combination skin: ◎ 75%+ say good for combination/oily; ○ 50%+ say good for combination/oily; △ 'slippery'/'sebum' in 5%+ of reviews; △ brand advises a second wash for oily skin; — no comparable independent data
Sensitive skin: △ fragrance listed; △ essential oil listed; △ irritation topic in 10%+ of reviews; ○ 70%+ 'gentle, no irritation' (survey); ○ irritation topic in under 5% of reviews; — no comparable independent data
Sunscreen & light makeup: △ 'doesn't cleanse well' in 20%+ of reviews; ○ 50%+ very satisfied with cleansing (survey); ○ 3+ independent sources: sunscreen comes off; ○ brand: one wash is enough for sunscreen; — no comparable independent data
Heavy or waterproof makeup: × brand advises a separate remover; × 'doesn't cleanse well' in 20%+ of reviews; × 3+ independent sources need a second wash; △ 50%+ very satisfied, no remover advice; — no comparable independent data
Gentle vs cleansing power
Korean data as shares of reviews, so products with different review counts compare.
'doesn't cleanse well' in 26.3% of reviews (93 of 353, Hwahae)
Hwahae shares = topic mentions ÷ Hwahae review count (24 Sep 2026); the two may not cover exactly the same reviews. Olive Young shares = buyer survey on the listing (1 Oct 2026).
The picks, one by one
1
make p:rem
Pick for: Sunscreen and light-makeup days
Photo: the 30 ml size of the same formula.
make p:rem
Safe me. Relief Moisture Gentle Cleansing Milk
200 ml
The everyday pick for sunscreen and a light base.
It was #1 in Olive Young KR water/milk sales on 1 Oct 2026 as a Sanrio collab set. Its Hwahae review topics couldn't be collected, so its downsides rest on 40 brand-store reviews.
Good for
You wear sunscreen or a light base most days
Skip it if
You avoid essential oils
Pros
20 of 40 brand-store reviews: gentle
Brand: one wash is enough on sunscreen days
Cons
Bergamot and clary oils in the list
Needs a remover for heavy makeup (brand)
Images: make p:rem official store
Not confirmed to be the same formula as the Korean version (as of 5 Oct 2026): Sephora US, Amazon (MAKEP:REM Store), StyleKorean
The gentle pick at Sephora US; weaker on long-wear base.
2nd on Hwahae (24 Sep 2026) and a Hwahae Best New Product Awards 2025 H2 winner; on its Olive Young KR listing (1,234 reviews), 74% say 'gentle' but 56% are very satisfied with cleansing.
Good for
Your skin reacts easily and your makeup is light
Skip it if
You wear fixing cushion or eyeliner
Pros
At Sephora US and Olive Young US
No fragrance listed; vegan (brand)
Cons
17 of 70 low-star-heavy reviews: leftover makeup; 5: eye stinging
The low-price pick: gentle-feeling, weak on makeup, not vegan.
It has the lowest bottle price of the 6 sold in the US ($14.24 sale at Olive Young Global, as of 1 Oct 2026). On Hwahae (4th, 4.60 from 3,917 reviews, 24 Sep 2026), about a quarter of reviews say it doesn't cleanse well.
Good for
You want a low price per bottle
Skip it if
You want a vegan formula
Pros
Own Naver store survey: 74% 'very satisfied' on irritation (review events run there)
Refill sets in Korea
Cons
Milk protein extract and lavender oil
Amino-acid cleansers at only 3 ppm and 2.55 ppm
Images: DEWYTREE official store
Not confirmed to be the same formula as the Korean version (as of 5 Oct 2026): Amazon (Dewytree Store), YesStyle
The moisturizing-feel pick for dry skin and little makeup.
On Hwahae, 'moisturizing' has 409 mentions, but its top topic is 'doesn't cleanse well' at 557, about a quarter of reviews. It was 2nd in Olive Young KR sales on 1 Oct 2026 as a collab refill set.
Good for
Your skin feels tight after foaming cleansers
Skip it if
You wear waterproof makeup
Pros
Sunflower seed oil 30% (brand)
Vegan (brand)
Cons
110 Hwahae mentions: waterproof won't come off
Ingredient lists differ between sellers
Images: Isntree official site
Not confirmed to be the same formula as the Korean version (as of 5 Oct 2026): Amazon, Olive Young Global, StyleKorean
The big-bottle pick for combination skin; keep it out of your eyes.
At 300 ml it's the largest bottle here; its Olive Young KR survey (1 Oct 2026) shows 62% 'good for combination', 74% 'gentle' and 55% very satisfied with cleansing.
Good for
You have combination or oily skin
Skip it if
Your eyes sting easily
Pros
0% call the cleansing disappointing
No fragrance listed; pH 6.0 (brand)
Cons
In 103 low-star-heavy reviews: 5 eye stinging, 12 oily film
Images: JUMISO official store
Not confirmed to be the same formula as the Korean version (as of 5 Oct 2026): JUMISO US store (jumiso.us), StyleKorean
The only foam of the seven; read its label cautions first.
7th in Olive Young KR water/milk sales on 1 Oct 2026, where it shows 19,742 reviews, but only 19 reviews on Hwahae, at 3.84 (24 Sep 2026).
Good for
You wear sunscreen or a light base
Skip it if
You're pregnant, or buying for a child under 3
Pros
3 independent sources: sunscreen comes off
Foam that doesn't run
Cons
4 independent sources: heavy makeup needs a second wash; 4 mention tightness
Tea tree leaf oil; scent complaints
Label caution: The Korean label says to avoid it if you are pregnant or may be pregnant, during your period, or if you have diabetes, poor circulation, kidney failure, an infection, redness or a known sensitivity to one of its ingredients, and never to use it on children aged 3 or under.
An award winner sold only in Korea; contains fragrance.
Hwahae Best New Product Awards 2026 H1 winner, 11th in the Hwahae ranking (24 Sep 2026), at ₩36,000(logbe.co.kr (Korea), as of 1 Oct 2026) for 250 ml (₩144/ml(₩36,000 ÷ 250 ml at logbe.co.kr (Korea), as of 1 Oct 2026 · calculated by Seoulvanie)).
Good for
You're shopping in Korea
Skip it if
You avoid fragrance
Pros
Hwahae award winner, 2026 H1
pH 4.72 (brand)
Cons
About a quarter of Hwahae reviews: doesn't cleanse well
Quotable reviews only from its own store
Images: Logbe official site
Korea-only · US: not found at Amazon US, eBay, iHerb, Olive Young Global, YesStyle, Sephora US, Olive Young US (checked 25 Sep 2026 – 1 Oct 2026). You can buy it in Korea. We'll add a store here if that changes.
How to choose
You wear sunscreen or a light base and want one gentle step → make p:rem
Your skin reacts easily and you want a US store → S.NATURE
In Korea, cleansing milks sell on gentleness; the shared weak spot is cleansing power, with 'doesn't cleanse well' in about a quarter of Hwahae reviews for DEWYTREE, Isntree and Logbe alike.
Olive Young counts each listing: on 1 Oct 2026, four of the seven reached their best rank as a set or refill listing.
Korean shoppers in their own words
Short excerpts from real Korean reviews, translated.
make p:rem
“Gentle, doesn't leave my skin tight. I like it.”
5/5 · make p:rem official online store
“I have combination, sensitive skin and got some irritation around my cheekbones.”
3/5 · make p:rem official online store
Isntree
“It took off my makeup better than I expected and felt gentle.”
4/5 · dehydrated oily skin · Hwahae
“I tested it with sunscreen on my hand, and it didn't come off well.”
2/5 · Isntree official online store
DEWYTREE
“It cleanses gently and my skin feels comfortable, with little tightness.”
5/5 · DEWYTREE official Naver store
“Way too slippery and it just doesn't cleanse.”
1/5 · DEWYTREE official Naver store
S.NATURE
“The cleansing isn't super strong, but light makeup comes off fine, with no residue.”
5/5 · Olive Young Korea
“Gentle and soft, but it really stings my eyes.”
2/5 · Olive Young Korea
Blanc Nature
“Press the pump and a dense foam comes right up. It doesn't drip off your hand.”
dehydrated oily skin · 30s · Naver Blog
“I don't like the scent, and it feels tight after washing.”
sensitive skin · Naver Blog
JUMISO
“If it gets in your eyes it really hurts. No irritation on my skin, though.”
1/5 · Olive Young Korea
“One cleanse isn't enough; it leaves a thin oily film.”
2/5 · Olive Young Korea
Logbe
“My skin doesn't feel tight after washing, and even stubborn sunscreen washes off.”
5/5 · Logbe official online store
“Gentle and moist, but the price is a real barrier.”
5/5 · Logbe official online store
Excerpts from Korean shoppers' reviews on Hwahae · Olive Young Korea · Naver Blog · the brands' own online stores (make p:rem, Isntree, DEWYTREE (Naver), Logbe — reviews hosted by the brand, not independent), posted Jun 2021 – Sep 2026, translated by Seoulvanie. Not our own use. DEWYTREE: the brand runs review events on the store these quotes come from.
pH and fragrance are as the brand states or as printed in the Korean ingredient list. Olive Young and Hwahae ranks and ratings are in the Korea table above.
Buying it where you are
United States
As of 1 Oct 2026, Sephora US sells make p:rem and S.NATURE, Olive Young US sells S.NATURE, JUMISO sells through jumiso.us, and make p:rem and DEWYTREE have official brand stores on Amazon. Olive Young Global, which ships from Korea, carries the rest except Logbe, which isn't sold outside Korea.
Store
Price
Sold by
make p:rem
Not confirmed to be the same formula as the Korean version (as of 5 Oct 2026): Sephora US, StyleKorean, Amazon (MAKEP:REM Store)
Checked in United States: Amazon US (1 Oct 2026), eBay (1 Oct 2026), iHerb (1 Oct 2026), Jolse (1 Oct 2026), jumiso.us (1 Oct 2026), Olive Young Global (1 Oct 2026), Olive Young US (1 Oct 2026), Sephora US (1 Oct 2026), StyleKorean (1 Oct 2026), YesStyle (1 Oct 2026).
Our pick
For most readers · make p:rem
For most readers, get make p:rem's cleansing milk: Korea's data put it first for sunscreen and light-makeup days.
It leads Hwahae's cleansing lotion and cream ranking at 4.66 from 9,152 reviews (24 Sep 2026), was #1 in Olive Young KR water/milk sales on 1 Oct 2026 as a Sanrio collab set, and is sold at Sephora US. Keep a remover for waterproof mascara.
Otherwise: your skin reacts easily and you want a US store → S.NATURE
Otherwise: you have combination or oily skin → JUMISO
Otherwise: your skin is dry and you rarely wear makeup → Isntree
Otherwise: you want the lowest bottle price in the US → DEWYTREE
Where to buy each one
make p:rem
Not confirmed to be the same formula as the Korean version (as of 5 Oct 2026): Sephora US
Prices were checked on the date shown and can change. Affiliate links will replace these store links after program approval.
Reference
Questions, answered
How do you use a Korean cleansing milk?
Use it on a dry face with dry hands: massage for about a minute, then rinse with lukewarm water or wipe it off. make p:rem, S.NATURE, Isntree and JUMISO all describe this, and Blanc Nature's foam also goes on a dry face. For waterproof eye makeup, S.NATURE and make p:rem advise a separate remover first.
Which Korean cleansing milk suits sensitive skin?
S.NATURE and JUMISO have the clearest independent data: 74% of each one's Olive Young KR survey answers say 'gentle, no irritation'. Both also have eye-stinging reports, so keep them out of your eyes and patch test first. Logbe lists fragrance; make p:rem, DEWYTREE and Blanc Nature contain essential oils, and Sephora US's page for make p:rem notes under one percent synthetic fragrance.
Will a cleansing milk remove waterproof mascara?
No, none of these seven is a waterproof remover. make p:rem, S.NATURE, DEWYTREE and Logbe advise a separate remover for waterproof or heavy makeup, and Isntree has 110 Hwahae mentions of waterproof makeup not coming off. Take eye makeup off with an eye and lip remover first.
Do I need to double cleanse after a cleansing milk?
Not on sunscreen or light-base days with make p:rem or Logbe, whose brands say one wash is enough then. After heavier makeup, add a foam cleanser: both brands say so, DEWYTREE advises a second cleanser when needed, and Korean reviews of S.NATURE, JUMISO and Blanc Nature report needing one.
Where can I buy them in the US, and are they the same?
Sephora US has make p:rem and S.NATURE, and JUMISO sells through jumiso.us. Olive Young Global, which ships from Korea, carries the others except Logbe, which is sold only in Korea. For Isntree, ingredient listings differ between sellers, so check the list on the box you receive.
Can I use a cleansing milk while pregnant?
Not Blanc Nature: its Korean label says to avoid it if you are pregnant or may be pregnant. It also says never to use it on children aged 3 or under. The label cautions we recorded for the other six don't mention pregnancy; ask your doctor before starting any new product while pregnant or breastfeeding.
